Search Went Too Far? When Evidence Gets Thrown Out

When police get evidence by violating the Fourth Amendment, a court can throw it out. That's called suppression. Common ways it happens: police search places or take items a warrant doesn't cover, seize something that isn't obviously illegal, go too far during a pat-down, or hold you longer than a stop allows. Suppression isn't automatic. There are exceptions, such as good faith and inevitable discovery, and in Kansas your attorney raises the issue with a motion to suppress. The prosecution then has to prove the search was lawful.
What Is the Exclusionary Rule?
The exclusionary rule bars prosecutors from using evidence police got through an unconstitutional search or seizure. The Supreme Court adopted it for federal cases in Weeks v. United States (1914) and applied it to state cases in Mapp v. Ohio (1961), so it binds every Kansas police department and prosecutor.
The rule also reaches evidence police found because of the illegal search, often called "fruit of the poisonous tree." If an unlawful search leads officers to a second location or a confession, that evidence can be excluded too.
How Suppression Works in Kansas
Under K.S.A. 22-3216, a defendant affected by an unlawful search can file a written motion to suppress, stating the facts that show the search was illegal. It's usually filed before trial. Once it's filed, the burden is on the prosecution to prove the search and seizure were lawful.
When Does a Search Exceed the Scope of a Warrant?
A search warrant has to describe the place to be searched and the things to be seized. Police can search only where the listed items could reasonably be found, and only for those items. A search can go too far in several ways:
Searching places the warrant doesn't cover. A warrant for one apartment doesn't cover the unit next door. Whether it covers a detached building or a vehicle depends on how the warrant describes the property.
Looking where the items couldn't be. A warrant for a stolen TV doesn't let officers open a jewelry box.
Searching people who aren't named. In Ybarra v. Illinois (1979), police had a warrant to search a bar and its bartender. They frisked every customer and found heroin in Ventura Ybarra's pocket. The Supreme Court held the search of Ybarra was unconstitutional, because being in a place being searched doesn't by itself give police a reason to search you.
Seizing items the warrant doesn't list, unless the plain view rule applies (below).
Unnecessary destruction. In United States v. Ramirez (1998), the Supreme Court said excessive or unnecessary destruction of property can violate the Fourth Amendment even when the entry is lawful. It also said that doesn't automatically mean the evidence gets suppressed.
When Can Police Seize Something in Plain View?
The plain view rule lets officers seize evidence without a warrant if:
They're lawfully in the place where they see it,
Its illegal nature is immediately apparent, meaning they have probable cause to believe it's contraband or evidence of a crime without further investigation, and
They have a lawful right to get to it.
The second requirement is where many seizures fail. In Arizona v. Hicks (1987), officers in an apartment for a shooting moved stereo equipment to read the serial numbers and learned it was stolen. The Supreme Court held that moving the equipment was a new search, and it needed probable cause the officers didn't have.
What Happened in United States v. McLevain
Officers had a warrant to search Roger McLevain's home for an escaped work-release inmate. A narcotics detective noticed a twist tie and a cut cigarette filter under a bed, a spoon with residue in the garage, and an unlabeled bottle of clear liquid. He field-tested the spoon, used the items to get a second warrant, and found methamphetamine and cash. The Sixth Circuit reversed McLevain's conviction. The items were ordinary objects with no connection to the fugitive the warrant was for, their criminal nature wasn't immediately apparent, and the detective should have gotten a warrant before seizing them.
How Far Can a Pat-Down Go?
Under Terry v. Ohio (1968), an officer who has reasonable suspicion that you're involved in a crime can briefly stop you. If the officer also reasonably suspects you're armed and dangerous, they can pat down your outer clothing for weapons. Reasonable suspicion has to rest on specific facts, not a hunch.
A pat-down is for weapons only. It isn't a search for evidence:
Plain feel: If an officer feels something whose identity as contraband is immediately apparent, they can seize it. But in Minnesota v. Dickerson (1993), an officer felt a small lump in a man's jacket, decided it wasn't a weapon, and kept squeezing and manipulating it until he concluded it was crack cocaine. The Supreme Court held that went beyond what a frisk allows.
Going into pockets: In State v. Spagnola (2012), the Kansas Supreme Court held that a search of a driver's pockets went past what a weapons pat-down allows. (More on that case on our consent searches page.)
Can Evidence From a Prolonged Stop Be Used?
Not if the stop was unlawfully extended. A traffic stop can last only as long as needed to handle the reason for it, such as checking your license and writing a ticket. In Rodriguez v. United States (2015), the Supreme Court held that police can't extend a completed traffic stop to run a drug-dog sniff unless they have reasonable suspicion of another crime.
What Happened in State v. Coleman
A Reno County deputy stopped Coleman for speeding. About five minutes in, he learned Coleman was on parole, and he then held him for at least 35 minutes waiting for a parole officer to arrive and search him. No speeding ticket was written. The Kansas Supreme Court found the deputy had reasonable suspicion for a temporary detention. But under the parole statute in effect then, holding Coleman for a parole violation required a written arrest-and-detain order, and the deputy didn't have one. Because the extended detention was unlawful, the cash, cocaine and paraphernalia found afterward had to be suppressed.
When Is Evidence From a Bad Search Not Thrown Out?
The exclusionary rule has exceptions. Prosecutors often argue one of these:
Good faith: officers reasonably relied on a warrant that later turned out to be invalid (United States v. Leon, 1984).
Inevitable discovery: the prosecution proves police would have found the evidence lawfully anyway (Nix v. Williams, 1984).
Independent source: police also got the evidence through a separate, lawful route (Murray v. United States, 1988).
Attenuation: the link between the illegal conduct and the evidence is too weak, for example because of an intervening event (Utah v. Strieff, 2016).
Whether an exception applies depends on the facts, and the prosecution has to prove it.
Think the Search Went Too Far?
A defense attorney can review the warrant, the reports and any video to see whether police went past what the law allows, then file a motion to suppress. When key evidence is suppressed, charges are sometimes reduced or dismissed. Learn more about motions to suppress evidence, or call Roth Davies at (913) 451-9500 for a free consultation.
Suppression FAQs
Can prosecutors use evidence from an illegal search?
Generally, no. Under the exclusionary rule, evidence from an unconstitutional search can be suppressed in Kansas state court (Mapp v. Ohio), unless an exception applies.
Does the court have to throw out illegally seized evidence?
Not always. Exceptions like good faith, inevitable discovery, independent source and attenuation can let the evidence in.
What happens if police search outside what the warrant allows?
Evidence found outside the warrant's limits can be suppressed, unless another exception, like plain view, covers it.
Can police search everyone at a location named in a warrant?
No. Being somewhere police are searching doesn't by itself justify searching you (Ybarra v. Illinois).
Can police take something that isn't listed in the warrant?
Only if they're lawfully there and it's immediately apparent the item is contraband or evidence of a crime. Moving or inspecting an item to find out is a new search (Arizona v. Hicks).
Can police reach into my pockets during a pat-down?
Not to look for evidence. A frisk is a pat-down of outer clothing for weapons. Police can remove something only if it feels like a weapon or is immediately recognizable as contraband (Minnesota v. Dickerson).
Can police hold me after a traffic stop to wait for a drug dog?
Not without reasonable suspicion of another crime. Extending a finished stop for a dog sniff violates the Fourth Amendment (Rodriguez v. United States).
Who has to prove the search was legal in Kansas?
The prosecution. Once you file a motion to suppress under K.S.A. 22-3216, the State has the burden of proving the search and seizure were lawful.
